Blue Crab Claws: How to Cook and Eat Them

November 16, 2026

Blue crab claws are some of the best meat on the crab, and a lot of people don't know what to do with them. They're also sold on their own, which is a good way to get a lot of claw meat without picking crabs.

What you're getting

Claw meat is darker than body meat, and it has a stronger, sweeter flavor. It comes from the muscles the crab uses most, which is why it holds up well to seasoning. Cocktail claws, sometimes called fingers, are the claw's tip pulled whole with a bit of shell left on, so they're easy to pick up and eat.

Boiled with Old Bay

For four people you'll want about two pounds of claws. Bring a gallon of water to a boil with a third of a cup of Old Bay and two halved lemons. Add the claws and boil them for six to eight minutes, until they're heated through. Drain them well and serve them with melted butter and lemon.

Garlic butter

Melt six tablespoons of butter in a large skillet over medium heat. Add eight minced garlic cloves and cook them for a minute or two. Add two pounds of cracked claws and toss them to coat. Cook five to six minutes, stirring, then finish with lemon juice and chopped parsley. Cracking the claws first lets the butter in.

Fried

Heat oil to 350 degrees. Soak cracked claws in buttermilk for ten minutes, then dredge them in a cup of flour mixed with a teaspoon of Cajun seasoning. Fry them in batches for three to four minutes until they're golden and crisp, and drain them on paper towels. For a thicker crust, use cornmeal with the flour.

How to eat them

Crack the shell with a cracker or a mallet at the widest point. Pull the shell apart carefully and lift out the meat. There's a thin piece of cartilage in the center, so pull it out slowly and the meat comes out in one piece. Dip it in butter or cocktail sauce.

Cocktail claws you can eat cold with a spicy dipping sauce, or warm in butter. For a dipping sauce, mix a cup of ketchup with two tablespoons of horseradish, a tablespoon of lemon juice, and a little hot sauce.

Claw meat is a good value for the flavor you get.

Bayou Treasures Seafood, Larose, Louisiana. 985-570-0575.

blog author avatar

Theron McCarthy

Owner & CEO of Bayou Treasures Seafood. Over 30 years of Seafood and Entrepreneurial Business experience.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog